We Are Accepting New Clients Online and In-Person 

The People-Pleasing Problem Nobody Talks About: Losing Your Preferences

You might be easygoing, flexible, and thoughtful. You may rarely insist on a restaurant, choose the movie, or say what you would prefer to do. When someone asks, “What do you want?” you might answer, “I don’t mind.”

Sometimes, that’s true. But if you often find yourself unsure, or automatically choose what seems easiest for everyone else, you may have become so used to accommodating others that your own preferences are harder to hear.

People-pleasing is often discussed in terms of saying yes too much or struggling to set boundaries. There can be a quieter part of the experience, too: losing touch with what you like, want, or feel comfortable with.

This doesn’t mean there is anything wrong with you. Adapting to other people can be a way of maintaining connection or avoiding tension. Over time, though, it can leave you feeling disconnected from your own choices.

How people-pleasing can make your preferences harder to hear

When you’re used to checking how everyone else might react, your attention may go outward before you have time to notice what you think. You might ask yourself:

  • What would make this easiest for everyone?
  • What answer will keep the peace?
  • What do they want me to say?
  • Will it seem selfish if I choose differently?

These questions may happen quickly, sometimes before you’re aware of them. The more often you prioritize other people’s comfort, the less practice you may

Picking up where it cut off:

…the less practice you may have noticing what you want before you respond. You might still have preferences, but they can feel faint, unclear, or difficult to trust.

Signs you may be losing touch with your preferences

This can show up in small, everyday moments, not only in major decisions. You might:

  • Default to “I’m fine with anything,” even when you have a preference.
  • Feel anxious or guilty when someone asks you to choose.
  • Change your answer after noticing what another person wants.
  • Realize you’re unhappy with a decision only after agreeing to it.
  • Feel resentful when others make plans without considering you.
  • Need a lot of reassurance that your choice is okay.

None of these signs alone proves that you are a people-pleaser. They can, however, be an invitation to get curious about how often your own comfort and preferences are part of the decision.

Why it can feel hard to say what you want

Expressing a preference may feel surprisingly vulnerable if you expect disagreement, disappointment, or conflict. Perhaps, at some point, keeping others happy felt safer than risking tension. Or perhaps you learned that being agreeable was part of being caring, easy to be around, or a “good” partner, friend, or family member.

Those patterns can make sense in the context in which they developed. They may have helped you navigate relationships or difficult circumstances. The challenge is that a strategy that once helped you feel connected can eventually make it harder to feel connected to yourself.

Reconnecting with what you like and need

You don’t have to start with a major boundary or a dramatic change. Rebuilding awareness of your preferences can begin with small, low-pressure choices.

Pause before answering

When someone asks what you’d like, give yourself a moment before responding. Try asking yourself, “What would I choose if I didn’t have to manage anyone else’s reaction?” You don’t have to share the answer immediately; noticing it is a meaningful first step.

Practise with low-stakes decisions

Choose a meal, activity, or time that works for you and state it simply. For example: “I’d prefer the earlier time,” or “I’m in the mood for something quiet.” Small choices offer a chance to practise without making every decision feel loaded.

Notice your body’s cues

You may notice a sense of ease, interest, tension, or reluctance when you consider different options. These reactions aren’t always a clear yes or no, but they can offer useful information alongside your thoughts.

Allow preferences to change

You’re allowed to want something different from what you wanted before. You’re also allowed to change your mind when new information comes up. A preference doesn’t have to be permanent or perfectly reasoned to be worth noticing.

Expect some discomfort

If you’re used to accommodating others, expressing a preference may feel uncomfortable at first. Discomfort doesn’t automatically mean you’ve done something wrong. You can be considerate of other people while still letting your own perspective matter.

What if I genuinely don’t know what I want?

Not knowing is a valid answer. You don’t have to force yourself to produce a preference on demand. You might try asking for time: “I’m not sure yet, can I think about it?” You could also narrow the options: “I don’t know what I want for dinner, but I know I’d rather stay in.”

Curiosity is often more helpful than self-criticism. Instead of asking, “Why can’t I just decide?” you might wonder, “What makes this choice hard for me?” Over time, noticing your reactions can help you recognize what feels comfortable, meaningful, or unwanted.

How therapy can help with people-pleasing

Therapy can offer a supportive space to explore how people-pleasing developed and how it affects your relationships and sense of self. Together with a therapist, you might practise recognizing your needs, expressing preferences, setting boundaries, and responding to guilt or worry when you make a choice for yourself.

Therapy isn’t about becoming less caring or considerate. It can help you include yourself in that care, too.

Key takeaways

  • People-pleasing can make it harder to notice or express your own preferences.
  • Automatically saying “I don’t mind” may be a habit, not proof that you have no preferences.
  • Small, everyday choices can help you practise listening to yourself.
  • Feeling uncomfortable when you speak up doesn’t necessarily mean your choice is wrong.
  • Therapy can help you explore these patterns and build greater self-trust.

Frequently asked questions

Is people-pleasing the same as being kind?

No. Kindness involves care and consideration, while people-pleasing may involve routinely setting aside your own needs to avoid conflict or disapproval. The two can overlap, but you can be kind while still having preferences and boundaries.

Why do I struggle to know what I want?

There can be many reasons. If you’re accustomed to focusing on other people’s reactions, you may have less practice checking in with your own preferences. Stress, uncertainty, or fear of disappointing someone can also make choices feel more difficult.

How can I express a preference without feeling selfish?

Start with a simple, respectful statement: “I’d prefer to meet earlier,” or “I’d like to choose this time.” You don’t need to justify every preference. It can take practice to feel comfortable, especially if you’re used to prioritizing others.

Can therapy help with people-pleasing?

Therapy can help you explore where people-pleasing shows up, understand what may be driving it, and practise expressing your needs in ways that feel manageable. The approach will depend on your experiences and goals.

Explore related support

If people-pleasing is affecting your relationships or making it difficult to feel connected to yourself, Karkiu Psychotherapy & Counselling offers individual therapy in Vaughan and online across Ontario. Learn about individual therapy or book a consultation.This article is for general information and is not a substitute for assessment, diagnosis, or psychotherapy.

Clinical Director, Registered Psychotherapist

Jacklyn Chung

“I truly believe that the purpose of life is to love — to learn to love others and to learn to love ourselves.”

Hello, my name is Jacklyn and I am the Founder of Karkiu Psychotherapy and Counselling. I love seeing you take this first step towards your inner healing and am happy to ease you into the process of therapy! I am a Registered Psychotherapist with CRPO and have been working in the field of mental health and education for over 10 years. As the Clinical Director, I oversee all cases that come through the practice – whether with me or with one of our Associates.

As your therapist, I use a balance between comfort and challenge in helping you discover who you are today, work on healing from past wounds, and improve your relationships. The aim is for you to develop a secure attachment within yourself and a sense of self-acceptance in who you are as a whole. We focus on strengths and self-compassion to assist you in building skills that will help you remain resilient and gritty. 

My clients are typically adult individuals who struggle with depression, anxiety, trauma, grief, identity loss, and relationship issues. I use a client-centered approach that empowers the individual to meaningfully regulate their inner experiences through culturally sensitive techniques, mindfulness practice, emotion-focused and trauma-informed theories.

I hope that we have the honour of working with you to discover, shape, and implement whatever healing looks like for you!

  • Depression | Suicide Ideation
  • Anxiety | Stress | Burnout
  • Work or School Related Stresses
  • Trauma including Childhood Trauma
  • Relationship Issues
  • Anxious or Avoidant Attachment Styles
  • Family Conflict
  • Sex and Intimacy
  • Grief | Life Transitions
  • Identity Development | Racial Identity
  • Bipolar Disorder
  • Borderline Personality Disorder 
  • Clinical Supervision
  • Therapist Identity
  • Intersectional Lens
  • Trauma-Informed
  • Emotion-Centered
  • ACT
  • Attachment
  • Compassion-Focused
  • DBT
  • Somatic Therapy
  • English
  • Cantonese
  • Registered Psychotherapist (Independent Practice) with College of Registered Psychotherapists of Ontario (CRPO)
  • Canadian Certified Counsellor with Canadian Counselling and Psychotherapy Association (CCPA)
  • Master of Education (MEd) in Counselling Psychology from University of Ottawa
  • Master of Teaching (MT) in Intermediate/Senior Division from University of Toronto (OISE)
  • Bachelor of Science (BSc) in Honours Psychology and Human Resources Minor from University of Waterloo
  • EMDR Part 1 and 2 Intensive Training with EMDR Consulting
  • DBT Certification Training
  • Applied Suicide Intervention Skills Training (ASIST) with LivingWorks and trained with Kids Help Phone Crisis Text Line as a Crisis Responder
  • “The Empowered Supervisor” Training and is a CRPO-qualified Clinical Supervisor
  • Formerly an Ontario Certified Teacher (OCT)
  • Course Author and Faculty for the Becoming Institute